This week my dear friend, a second waver, we'll call her, and I were talking about the way we judge women in our culture. This conversation came up because I had just submitted a grant (cross your fingers!) that addresses the way that women are represented in the media. The focus of the grant is on raising awareness with young women that the messages they are sent, those very subtle messages, are deceiving.
She wondered if some of this obsession women have with looks is cultural and she talked about how she wore make-up at different points in her life depending on where she lived. Then we moved into a conversation on how easily we silently judge other women about what they wear, how they look, why they dress the way they do, and so on. We talked about how so many young women today wax away EVERYTHING and do so in the name of "cleanliness."
I harp on this topic today because I wonder how we can break this so-called cycle. As self-proclaimed feminists we are aware of the pressure to wax, paint our face, dress nice, yet as much as we fight against this pressure, we still bow to it, in many ways. I wonder, is there a balance? The documentary, Miss Representation, which I have written about previously features a gorgeous blond as filmmaker. She briefly mentions her struggles as an actor being typecast as the dumb blond, but I feel like she just glosses over how she fits into this whole paradigm.
I think, too, of some of my favorite movies, those produced in England and Holland, like Mike Leigh's Secrets & Lies or Antonia's Line. Are these movies on my top ten because of the subject matter, the acting or the writing; or are these movies so good because the actors look like REAL people? When you live in a culture, (the U.S.) where everything presented to you is "perfect" it is hard to see what reality is. What is beauty when we only see it photo-shopped and touched up? How can we find real beauty and reject the artificial?
I know women who don't wear make-up and tend to dress in a non-conformist way, but even they are conforming to some sort of "look" that fits into their world. I think of a good friend of mine, a former student, who has a unique style that reminds me somewhat of Ellen, the CoverGirl herself.
I certainly don't have an answer to this big issue on this rainy Wednesday in New England. Perhaps I am thrown into these thoughts today as a teeter on the edge of PMS feeling bloated and fat, eagerly awaiting my period so this monthly slump will pass on. Maybe its because I went to my bridesmaid dress fitting the other day for my sister's wedding and felt huge in that oversize dress, literally four sizes more than I normally wear. Maybe its because I fell down the stairs two weeks ago and my lower back is still aching and discouraging me from running. Or maybe it's just that the media-owned-conglomerate is plain old patriarchal and the only way to avoid it is to turn it off.
Stop buying magazines that don't feature REAL women. Stop watching television that mis-represents us. Only watch International films. And when that woman walks by you wearing something you would not be caught dead in, say to yourself "you go girl" and let the judgment fade away.
Providing weekly critiques of theatre, film, books, politics and pop culture from a feminist perspective.
Wednesday, May 9, 2012
Monday, April 30, 2012
Do We Really Need Hundreds of Women's Centers? Duh!
One of my colleagues, who runs the University of Idaho Women's Center, posted this article by Mark Perry, a professor and writer on economics and finance issues. His main point is that since women are attending and graduating from college at higher rates than men than we don't need campus based Women's Centers.
Click here for article
What is interesting about the article is that he cuts and pastes mission statements from five women's centers who have main goals in promoting gender equity. He disputes this by stating that if there are more women than men at a college, there is no need to promote gender equity. Oh, Prof Perry, you just don't get it! Gender equity is not about filling the seats in the classroom. Gender equity is about how girls and women are treated in our world, which in case you haven't looked recently, ain't so hot. Shall I cite some examples as Perry did?
Click here for article
What is interesting about the article is that he cuts and pastes mission statements from five women's centers who have main goals in promoting gender equity. He disputes this by stating that if there are more women than men at a college, there is no need to promote gender equity. Oh, Prof Perry, you just don't get it! Gender equity is not about filling the seats in the classroom. Gender equity is about how girls and women are treated in our world, which in case you haven't looked recently, ain't so hot. Shall I cite some examples as Perry did?
- Women make less than men. White women in the 77 cent range, Black Women in the 67 cent range and Latina women in the 57 cent range to a white man's dollar.
- Over a billion women on the planet have been victimized by sexual violence. One billion.
- 17 out of 100 of our U.S. Senators are women. 17.
- Women hold only 3% of clout positions in the mainstream media (telecommunications, entertainment, publishing and advertising).
- Women comprise 7% of directors and 13% of film writers in the top 250 grossing films.
- The United States is 90th in the world in terms of women in national legislatures.
- Women hold 17% of the seats in the House of Representatives (the equivalent body in Rwanda is 56.3% female).
- Women are merely 3% of Fortune 500 CEOs.
- About 25% of girls will experience teen dating violence.
- The number of cosmetic surgical procedures performed on youth 18 or younger more than tripled from 1997 to 2007.
- Among youth 18 and younger, liposuctions nearly quadrupled between 1997 and 2007 and breast augmentations increased nearly six-fold in the same 10-year period.
- 65% of American women and girls report disordered eating behaviors.
Wednesday, April 18, 2012
Kettle One, Ladies Drink Vodka Too!
Sometimes I think I should call this blog "what really gets my goat" instead of The Feminist Critic. I was so overwhelmed with the "war against women" or "the fight to get the women's vote" that I couldn't focus on which of the latest attacks on women's reproductive rights or dismissal of women's opinions to address today. Hence I harken back to an advertisement that I see, far too often, often on the way to Boston, that drives me nuts.
Kettle One's Latest Advertising
I drink vodka. I have for years. It is my preferred liquor of choice. Many of my female friends also drink vodka. More of my female friends drink vodka than my male friends, many of whom prefer whiskey. Kettle One is my favorite vodka. I will drink Grey Goose or Belvedere or some of the catchy new vodkas that are out there. I will taste anything once. But Kettle One is my favorite. I have rich taste, I can't help it.
However, Kettle One's latest marketing campaign, directed by David O. Russell (Oscar nominated director of The Fighter), and featuring new music by Alberta Cross, which has been going on for far too long, includes three advertisements that include the following. In every single one of these advertisements, the men are drinking vodka together like they are part of some Secret Society. There is usually ONE woman shown with three men. They are drinking vodka on the rocks. The announcer always says "inspired by 300 years of tradition." And the end tag line is always "Gentlemen, this is vodka."
OK. Really? The subliminal statements in these ads make me want to boycott Kettle One. "Inspired by 300 years of tradition" could mean patriarchy or some patriarchal tradition, some old men's club that only allows women in if they are invited. I'm sure that's not what they meant, but since they don't tell us what that mean, we are left to guess. Is it inspired by 300 years of some old dudes pressing wheat? Is that what tradition stands for?
I believe the male owned Nolet Distillery in Holland knows that women drink vodka. They are trying to "reach out" to their male constituents and to reach men and let them know that vodka isn't just a "girly" drink. "Look, you can drink it on the rocks!" No juice or sour mix!" "It's tough. It's cool. It's Gentlemeny!" But can't we find marketing gurus in this day and age who can reach out to one group without stomping all over another? Why should I watch that commercial and feel like I am not allowed to be in this vodka drinking Gentlemen's club? I feel the same way whenever I watch South Park. All the commercials are about video games. I watch South Park. I think its funny and well-written, but I'm in my forties and I don't play World of Warcraft or Halo.
In the advertising's industry desperate struggle to reach men who don't watch television or drink vodka, they do so on the backs of women either rendering us invisible, making us part of the scenery or overlooking us all together. It's as if we were never invited to the table or to the bar.
Kettle One's Latest Advertising
I drink vodka. I have for years. It is my preferred liquor of choice. Many of my female friends also drink vodka. More of my female friends drink vodka than my male friends, many of whom prefer whiskey. Kettle One is my favorite vodka. I will drink Grey Goose or Belvedere or some of the catchy new vodkas that are out there. I will taste anything once. But Kettle One is my favorite. I have rich taste, I can't help it.
However, Kettle One's latest marketing campaign, directed by David O. Russell (Oscar nominated director of The Fighter), and featuring new music by Alberta Cross, which has been going on for far too long, includes three advertisements that include the following. In every single one of these advertisements, the men are drinking vodka together like they are part of some Secret Society. There is usually ONE woman shown with three men. They are drinking vodka on the rocks. The announcer always says "inspired by 300 years of tradition." And the end tag line is always "Gentlemen, this is vodka."
OK. Really? The subliminal statements in these ads make me want to boycott Kettle One. "Inspired by 300 years of tradition" could mean patriarchy or some patriarchal tradition, some old men's club that only allows women in if they are invited. I'm sure that's not what they meant, but since they don't tell us what that mean, we are left to guess. Is it inspired by 300 years of some old dudes pressing wheat? Is that what tradition stands for?
I believe the male owned Nolet Distillery in Holland knows that women drink vodka. They are trying to "reach out" to their male constituents and to reach men and let them know that vodka isn't just a "girly" drink. "Look, you can drink it on the rocks!" No juice or sour mix!" "It's tough. It's cool. It's Gentlemeny!" But can't we find marketing gurus in this day and age who can reach out to one group without stomping all over another? Why should I watch that commercial and feel like I am not allowed to be in this vodka drinking Gentlemen's club? I feel the same way whenever I watch South Park. All the commercials are about video games. I watch South Park. I think its funny and well-written, but I'm in my forties and I don't play World of Warcraft or Halo.
In the advertising's industry desperate struggle to reach men who don't watch television or drink vodka, they do so on the backs of women either rendering us invisible, making us part of the scenery or overlooking us all together. It's as if we were never invited to the table or to the bar.
Wednesday, April 11, 2012
Supporting Women
I've been wanting to write about women not supporting women but was trying to find a way to do so without cutting too close to home, so to speak. Being one not to hold something in for an extensive amount of time, especially if it is really bugging me, here goes nothing!
This semester I have seen entitled and elitist behavior, by women, who call themselves feminists. It's shocking. I talked with a close colleague about this and we discussed how this is so prevalent and troubling that it might be worthy of an article. I am hesitant to recommend any of my students go into academia as a career. Here I am, enjoying over 19 years of working with students and teaching in a public university, yet I would not recommend it. Dog eat dog. That pretty much sums it up. And I recently talked with one of my alums who is in a Master's program being chewed up and spit out by women who call themselves feminists in her women's center.
For me, this boils down to how we practice our feminism. We can say we are feminists and have a definition of what that might be or look like, but how we behave toward other women is an excellent test. Ashley Judd recently wrote a great piece about body image and the media and asked us to try to be better at not judging each other. http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/04/09/ashley-judd-slaps-media-in-the-face-for-speculation-over-her-puffy-appearance.html So there's one step. But treating each other with respect no matter what our job titles are is the next step.
In the institution of higher education we exist in a caste system. The support staff exist on the bottom, then the professional staff, than the faculty, than the administration. But it's really the faculty, I have found, that appreciate and perpetuate this system.
Some recent examples of entitlement in action (names removed of course to protect the not-so-innocent):
I thought I wanted to teach full time. I loved teaching and this was why I spent almost $70,000 to get my doctorate. I did this while working full time and teaching as an adjunct. And then I spent the next six years applying for every job I believed I was qualified for in New England. But a dear friend recently said to me after another rejection "You are not one of them. You're nice." What does this mean for the institution of academia, the very place where we try to teach our students to not only be critical thinkers, but also to become engaged citizens of their world. How can we demonstrate that practicing our feminism isn't just talk but action?
This semester I have seen entitled and elitist behavior, by women, who call themselves feminists. It's shocking. I talked with a close colleague about this and we discussed how this is so prevalent and troubling that it might be worthy of an article. I am hesitant to recommend any of my students go into academia as a career. Here I am, enjoying over 19 years of working with students and teaching in a public university, yet I would not recommend it. Dog eat dog. That pretty much sums it up. And I recently talked with one of my alums who is in a Master's program being chewed up and spit out by women who call themselves feminists in her women's center.
For me, this boils down to how we practice our feminism. We can say we are feminists and have a definition of what that might be or look like, but how we behave toward other women is an excellent test. Ashley Judd recently wrote a great piece about body image and the media and asked us to try to be better at not judging each other. http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/04/09/ashley-judd-slaps-media-in-the-face-for-speculation-over-her-puffy-appearance.html So there's one step. But treating each other with respect no matter what our job titles are is the next step.
In the institution of higher education we exist in a caste system. The support staff exist on the bottom, then the professional staff, than the faculty, than the administration. But it's really the faculty, I have found, that appreciate and perpetuate this system.
Some recent examples of entitlement in action (names removed of course to protect the not-so-innocent):
- A message left on my voice mail referring to one of the sweetest and nicest colleagues I have as a bitch
- Demanding water before a talk
- Being annoyed that we were showing a borrowed film to a group of middle school girls during spring break
I thought I wanted to teach full time. I loved teaching and this was why I spent almost $70,000 to get my doctorate. I did this while working full time and teaching as an adjunct. And then I spent the next six years applying for every job I believed I was qualified for in New England. But a dear friend recently said to me after another rejection "You are not one of them. You're nice." What does this mean for the institution of academia, the very place where we try to teach our students to not only be critical thinkers, but also to become engaged citizens of their world. How can we demonstrate that practicing our feminism isn't just talk but action?
Wednesday, April 4, 2012
You Can't Be What You Can't See
We've been showing this documentary, Miss Representation, as part of our Women's History Month program, our theme being Women Enacting Change. While this movie certainly has it's problems. like the fact that the majority of the celebrities who speak in it are gorgeous stereotypical women, it's underlying theme of how we are represented in television, the movies and in the news is significant. View the trailer here http://www.missrepresentation.org/
We hosted a showing of the movie in New Bedford as part of a collaboration with other women's agencies to a packed house. Then we showed it to a group of middle school girls for a day long empowerment event with the YWCA and the AAUW. Lastly we showed the entire movie on campus for anyone on campus or in the community. The group of about 50 people was made up mostly of community women. Some of these were mothers who brought their daughters to see the movie. These young women were riled up by the movie.
I asked them who in the audience identified as feminists and as some of them raised their hands, one girl said "I do now!" This is my takeaway. If one 90 minute film is going to help a middle school or high school girl identify with feminism then I need to show it everywhere. I showed the movie to an 8th grade class the other day and while we were watching the clip, my college student who was there to help me lead the discussion whispered that she "feels that way too" in reference to women hating their bodies. I let out a big internal sigh. This woman already identifies with feminism and gets what the media is doing to us, but still can't separate the message from the way it feels on the inside. We need to start younger.
This is my new plan of action: take this movie to young women.
Here are just a few disturbing facts from the film.
We hosted a showing of the movie in New Bedford as part of a collaboration with other women's agencies to a packed house. Then we showed it to a group of middle school girls for a day long empowerment event with the YWCA and the AAUW. Lastly we showed the entire movie on campus for anyone on campus or in the community. The group of about 50 people was made up mostly of community women. Some of these were mothers who brought their daughters to see the movie. These young women were riled up by the movie.
I asked them who in the audience identified as feminists and as some of them raised their hands, one girl said "I do now!" This is my takeaway. If one 90 minute film is going to help a middle school or high school girl identify with feminism then I need to show it everywhere. I showed the movie to an 8th grade class the other day and while we were watching the clip, my college student who was there to help me lead the discussion whispered that she "feels that way too" in reference to women hating their bodies. I let out a big internal sigh. This woman already identifies with feminism and gets what the media is doing to us, but still can't separate the message from the way it feels on the inside. We need to start younger.
This is my new plan of action: take this movie to young women.
Here are just a few disturbing facts from the film.
- Women hold only 3% of clout positions in the mainstream media (telecommunications, entertainment, publishing and advertising).
- Women comprise 7% of directors and 13% of film writers in the top 250 grossing films.
- The United States is 90th in the world in terms of women in national legislatures.
- Women hold 17% of the seats in the House of Representatives (the equivalent body in Rwanda is 56.3% female).
- Women are merely 3% of Fortune 500 CEOs.
- About 25% of girls will experience teen dating violence.
- The number of cosmetic surgical procedures performed on youth 18 or younger more than tripled from 1997 to 2007.
- Among youth 18 and younger, liposuctions nearly quadrupled between 1997 and 2007 and breast augmentations increased nearly six-fold in the same 10-year period.
- 65% of American women and girls report disordered eating behaviors.
Wednesday, March 14, 2012
The Childless Feminist
A few weeks ago I posted a link to The Current Conscience, a blog by LA feminist and writer, Yashar Ali (yes, he is a man!). I Don't Want to Have Kids. There were 13 likes and 10 comments. The article struck a chord with many of my friends, particularly those who are women. It felt good to see that many women felt like I did: frustrated, pressured and not valued for our choices. So for today's blog I thought I would write down all the things people have said to me about my choice, my very personal choice, to contribute to society in a different way than my friends and family who have children.
"That's the biggest mistake you'll ever make."
"It's good you know you'd be a bad parent."
"You're too young to make that decision."
"You're not too old" (Told this at 42 & 43 years old)
"There's nothing better in this world than having children."
"Why?"
"But you'd make such a good mom."
"But being pregnant is so amazing."
"Who will take care of you when you are old?" This question assumes that ALL children care for their aging parent, and this we know is not the case.
"Wow."
I would love to have readers add to this list. My sister, who is 28, and her fiance, are starting to feel this same pressure. What's frustrating about this is that she is 15 years younger than me, yet she is getting the same exact pressure from society. Why do we continue to remain stagnant or even go backwards as a culture? I also wonder if I would be questioned the same way if I was in a relationship with a woman rather than a man? Is this compulsory heterosexuality at work or some other term we haven't coined? Compulsory motherhood?
Take for instance the recent debates about contraception. Really? In 2012 a hot button topic of the Republican race for President is going to be whether women should have the right to contraception or not? It makes me sick. Our Ophthalmologist recently told us of a study she read (she is the mother of twins) that the happiest people in U.S. society are actually couples without children. Remember the term DINKs? Apparently as much as people claim that having children is the "best thing ever," it turns out the happiest people are those without the pressures of children.
Yet I remain proud that I have chosen, with my own free will, and in deep discussion with my partner, that we will choose to be a wonderful Aunt and Uncle to our nieces and nephews. We will continue to value the precious time we have together as a couple.
"That's the biggest mistake you'll ever make."
"It's good you know you'd be a bad parent."
"You're too young to make that decision."
"You're not too old" (Told this at 42 & 43 years old)
"There's nothing better in this world than having children."
"Why?"
"But you'd make such a good mom."
"But being pregnant is so amazing."
"Who will take care of you when you are old?" This question assumes that ALL children care for their aging parent, and this we know is not the case.
"Wow."
I would love to have readers add to this list. My sister, who is 28, and her fiance, are starting to feel this same pressure. What's frustrating about this is that she is 15 years younger than me, yet she is getting the same exact pressure from society. Why do we continue to remain stagnant or even go backwards as a culture? I also wonder if I would be questioned the same way if I was in a relationship with a woman rather than a man? Is this compulsory heterosexuality at work or some other term we haven't coined? Compulsory motherhood?
Take for instance the recent debates about contraception. Really? In 2012 a hot button topic of the Republican race for President is going to be whether women should have the right to contraception or not? It makes me sick. Our Ophthalmologist recently told us of a study she read (she is the mother of twins) that the happiest people in U.S. society are actually couples without children. Remember the term DINKs? Apparently as much as people claim that having children is the "best thing ever," it turns out the happiest people are those without the pressures of children.
Yet I remain proud that I have chosen, with my own free will, and in deep discussion with my partner, that we will choose to be a wonderful Aunt and Uncle to our nieces and nephews. We will continue to value the precious time we have together as a couple.
Thursday, March 1, 2012
Oscar Smoshcar
I posted quite a bit on my Facebook this past week about the sexist, racist tradition in Hollywood called the Academy Awards. Again there were no women nominated for best director. Here's one article I posted:
/http://www.salon.com/2012/02/25/the_oscars_woman_problem/
And in general, I got a fairly good response to the reality of how the Academy is made up of mostly white men who make all these decisions. (Sound familiar? Congress?). What really got me thinking, however, was one facebook "friend" who felt like it was women's fault for going to the types of movies that aren't good. The suggestion was that as consumers, women needed to make better choices about what they watch and that would somehow affect who wins for best director. Huh?
I'm not sure I buy this one. It feels a bit like victim-blaming and I'm just getting tired of women being blamed for a patriarchal institution that runs Hollywood. I agree that we need more women producing movies and you can be certain if I made enough money to finance movie making, I'd be first in line sending my best friend, Kristen Vermilyea, a fat check to produce some feminist movies. Certainly Tina Fey is putting her money where her mouth is and supporting women filmmakers, but there is only one Tina Fey. There is only one Oprah Winfrey. There are way more white men with money deciding what movies are going to be produced and what they will be about. Our stories don't get told because they are not the "everyman" experience, whatever that is.
So while I'm a fan of the fun extravagant night where we honor the best of the best in any industry, I'm just getting too cynical and old to enjoy this event that not only hasn't changed since I was a little girl dreaming of myself up on that stage accepting my award, but has seemed to take four steps back in any representation of racial and gender diversity. I boycotted it this year and I think that's my new plan of action for the future, until Hollywood catches on that women are over 50% of this world and deserve that same representation in film.
And isn't all this too similar to seeing an all male panel decide what laws should be passed on birth control? The backlash against women's rights is all too prevalent and present lately and that sets a sad tone for the future for little girls I love very much.
Side note: If this is an issue you care about, come to our showings of Miss Representation on March 1 and 28th at 5:30pm at UMass Dartmouth's Woodland Commons, or downtown New Bedford on March 8th at 6pm. "You can't be what you can't see!"
/http://www.salon.com/2012/02/25/the_oscars_woman_problem/
And in general, I got a fairly good response to the reality of how the Academy is made up of mostly white men who make all these decisions. (Sound familiar? Congress?). What really got me thinking, however, was one facebook "friend" who felt like it was women's fault for going to the types of movies that aren't good. The suggestion was that as consumers, women needed to make better choices about what they watch and that would somehow affect who wins for best director. Huh?
I'm not sure I buy this one. It feels a bit like victim-blaming and I'm just getting tired of women being blamed for a patriarchal institution that runs Hollywood. I agree that we need more women producing movies and you can be certain if I made enough money to finance movie making, I'd be first in line sending my best friend, Kristen Vermilyea, a fat check to produce some feminist movies. Certainly Tina Fey is putting her money where her mouth is and supporting women filmmakers, but there is only one Tina Fey. There is only one Oprah Winfrey. There are way more white men with money deciding what movies are going to be produced and what they will be about. Our stories don't get told because they are not the "everyman" experience, whatever that is.
So while I'm a fan of the fun extravagant night where we honor the best of the best in any industry, I'm just getting too cynical and old to enjoy this event that not only hasn't changed since I was a little girl dreaming of myself up on that stage accepting my award, but has seemed to take four steps back in any representation of racial and gender diversity. I boycotted it this year and I think that's my new plan of action for the future, until Hollywood catches on that women are over 50% of this world and deserve that same representation in film.
And isn't all this too similar to seeing an all male panel decide what laws should be passed on birth control? The backlash against women's rights is all too prevalent and present lately and that sets a sad tone for the future for little girls I love very much.
Side note: If this is an issue you care about, come to our showings of Miss Representation on March 1 and 28th at 5:30pm at UMass Dartmouth's Woodland Commons, or downtown New Bedford on March 8th at 6pm. "You can't be what you can't see!"
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)